Planning your first trip to Okinawa’s outer islands and wondering, “Which is better: Miyakojima or Ishigakijima?” You’re not alone—this is a common dilemma! Both islands offer unique charms and plenty of must-visit attractions, making the choice tough.
However, the best island for you depends on your travel preferences and goals. This article dives into the differences in experiences between Miyakojima and Ishigakijima, detailing their unique features to help you decide.
How Do Miyakojima and Ishigakijima Differ?
If you’re torn between Miyakojima and Ishigakijima, a quick overview of their differences can make choosing your destination easier.
Okinawa’s islands each have unique cultures and traditions, so doing some research beforehand is a smart move. Below, we highlight key differences between the two islands.
Geographical Differences Between Miyakojima and Ishigakijima
Despite both being part of Okinawa’s outer islands, Miyakojima and Ishigakijima have strikingly different landscapes.
Miyakojima is formed from uplifted Ryukyu limestone (coral reef layers), resulting in a flat island with no mountains or rivers. Even after rain, the sea remains crystal-clear, boasting exceptional beach transparency. Notably, Miyakojima is free of the venomous habu snake due to its underwater origin. The island is also connected to Irabu, Shimoji, Ikema, and Kurima islands by large bridges, allowing easy car access to multiple islands.
Ishigakijima is home to Okinawa’s highest peak, Mount Omoto (526 meters), at its center. The island is rich in rivers, mountains, and lush nature, hosting unique species like the crested serpent eagle. Ferries from Ishigakijima connect to Taketomi Island (famous for its red-tiled traditional villages), the UNESCO World Heritage-listed Iriomote Island, and Japan’s southernmost Hateruma Island.
Sakishima Islands
- Miyako Islands: Miyakojima, Irabu, Ikema, Kurima, Shimoji, Ogami, Tarama, Minna
- Yaeyama Islands: Ishigakijima, Taketomi, Iriomote, Yufu, Kohama, Kuroshima, Hateruma, Aragusuku, Yonaguni
Transportation Options for Miyakojima and Ishigakijima
Both Miyakojima and Ishigakijima are accessible by flights from major Japanese airports.
Miyakojima Airport has no international flights, but Shimoji Island Airport in Miyakojima City offers direct flights to Hong Kong, Taipei, and Seoul.
Each island has unique transportation options, so it’s worth checking in advance.
Main Flight Times
Here’s an estimate of one-way flight times from major airports:
| Departure City | Miyakojima | Ishigakijima |
|---|---|---|
| Hong Kong International Airport | ~2 hr 15 min (Shimoji Island Airport) | ~2 hr 5 min |
| Taipei Taoyuan Airport | ~1 hr 20 min (Shimoji Island Airport) | ~1 hr |
| Seoul Incheon Airport | ~2 hr 35 min (Shimoji Island Airport) | ~2 hr 55 min |
| Naha Airport | ~50 min | ~1 hr |
| Fukuoka Airport | ~2 hr | ~2 hr 10 min |
| Osaka Airport | ~2 hr 45 min | ~3 hr |
| Nagoya Airport | ~3 hr | ~3 hr 15 min |
| Haneda Airport | ~3 hr 15 min | ~3 hr 30 min |
| Sendai Airport | ~5 hr 20 min (with transfer) | ~5 hr 20 min (with transfer) |
| Sapporo Airport | ~7 hr (with transfer) | ~7 hr (with transfer) |
Island Transportation Options
- Miyakojima: Main transportation options include rental cars, buses, and taxis. Since bridges connect to Irabu, Ikema, and other islands, renting a car is the best way to maximize your exploration. Buses and taxis are viable but limit your schedule and range, so plan carefully.
- Ishigakijima: If your trip focuses on island-hopping (e.g., Taketomi or Iriomote), taxis may be more convenient than rental cars. The island’s ferry terminal is a key hub for non-drivers. Ishigakijima ferry services: https://aneikankou.co.jp/
Choose transportation based on your travel itinerary.
Travel Cost Comparison: Miyakojima vs. Ishigakijima
Travel costs for both islands are roughly comparable.
Both offer luxury resorts and budget-friendly guesthouses, with flight options ranging from full-service carriers like JAL/ANA to low-cost carriers (LCCs). By clarifying your travel goals, you can manage costs effectively.
Average Per-Person Travel Costs (based on the 2023 Okinawa Prefecture Tourism Statistics Report):
- Miyakojima: ~119,380 JPY
- Ishigakijima: ~134,305 JPY
Ishigakijima’s costs are generally about 15,000 JPY higher than Miyakojima’s.
| Cost Category | Miyakojima Average | Ishigakijima Average |
|---|---|---|
| Accommodation | 46,986 JPY | 54,626 JPY |
| Island Transportation | 18,014 JPY | 19,046 JPY |
| Souvenirs | 18,065 JPY | 18,672 JPY |
| Dining | 23,556 JPY | 25,117 JPY |
| Entertainment/Admission Fees | 11,624 JPY | 15,708 JPY |
| Other Expenses | 1,135 JPY | 1,136 JPY |
| Total | 119,380 JPY | 134,305 JPY |
Activity Differences: Miyakojima vs. Ishigakijima
Both islands offer a wealth of nature and cultural activities. Below are the standout experiences to help you create unforgettable memories.
Miyakojima Activity Highlights
- Crystal-Clear Waters: Miyakojima’s sea transparency ranks among the best in Okinawa, perfect for snorkeling, stand-up paddleboarding (SUP), and sea kayaking.
- Island-Hopping by Car: Drive across Irabu, Ikema, and Kurima bridges for a scenic road trip experience.
- Cultural Homestay Experience: Stay in a local guesthouse, join cooking sessions, or enjoy traditional Okinawan drinking rituals, ideal for repeat visitors.
Ishigakijima Activity Highlights
- Marine Adventures in Sekisei Lagoon: Located between Ishigakijima and Iriomote, this coral-rich lagoon is ideal for snorkeling, diving, and SUP.
- UNESCO World Heritage Iriomote Island: A 50-minute ferry ride takes you to Iriomote for jungle treks and unique ecological adventures.
- Rainy Day Activities: Even in bad weather, enjoy cave exploration, chili oil-making workshops, or painting traditional shisa statues.
Family Travel: Miyakojima or Ishigakijima?
- Miyakojima: Ideal for families with a rental car, offering easy access to Irabu, Ikema, and other scenic spots.
- Ishigakijima: Perfect for families without a driver’s license or those relying on public transport or guided tours, with easy ferry access to Taketomi and Iriomote.
Miyakojima Family Travel Tips
- Rental cars are essential for visiting remote beaches or luxury resorts, often located outside city centers.
- Buses or guided tours are possible but restrict your range of exploration.
Ishigakijima Family Travel Tips
- A 30-minute bus ride from the airport takes you to the ferry terminal, perfect for island-hopping to Taketomi or Iriomote without a car.
- For attractions like Kabira Bay, consider renting a car or using public buses.
Conclusion: Who Should Visit Miyakojima or Ishigakijima?
Best for Miyakojima:
- Those who love scenic drives across island bridges.
- Travelers seeking crystal-clear seas and marine activities.
- Visitors wanting to stay in luxury resorts.
Best for Ishigakijima:
- Those eager to island-hop to Taketomi, Iriomote, and beyond.
- Foodies craving Ishigaki beef, fresh seafood, and local flavors.
- Non-drivers or those less confident behind the wheel.
We hope this guide helps you plan the perfect Okinawa island adventure!
